الخميس، 6 نوفمبر 2014

Our addiction to criminalising human behaviour makes a mockery of private responsibility | Simon Jenkins

From drinking while pregnant to urinating on a war memorial, the laws ambition has no limits

If poisoning your foetus with alcohol is a crime, why is it not a crime to abort it? If alcoholism in pregnancy is attempted manslaughter, as a QC told the court of appeal this week, surely abortion is murder. Indeed if alcoholism before birth criminally harms a babys life, what about alcoholism and a dozen other cruelties after birth? How many are the misdeeds we inflict on our children to which Britains cult of criminality should now turn its attention?


We need a philosopher as Raymond Chandler would say and we need one fast. All we get are bloody lawyers. The motive for this weeks court case in London had nothing to do with the health of mother or child. It was blatantly financial. A local council is acting on behalf of a seven-year-old girl CP who suffers from acute foetal alcohol syndrome. The claimed cause was her mothers drinking during pregnancy. The suit is intended to shift the cost of caring for her from the council to the Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority on the grounds that the girl is victim of violence against the person.


Continue reading...



from Pregnancy | The Guardian http://ift.tt/1AsFZqD

ليست هناك تعليقات:

إرسال تعليق